Have you ever caught yourself saying, “I’m just not good at this,” and wondered what happens next?
What Is A “Growth Mindset” Vs. A “Fixed Mindset”?
You probably know the phrase at a surface level — that some people believe talent is set in stone while others think it can be developed — but the difference between a growth mindset and a fixed mindset is less about slogans and more about how you respond when things go wrong. In plain terms, a fixed mindset treats ability as a static label, while a growth mindset treats ability as something you can improve with effort, feedback, and time. You can decide which one runs the show in your head.
The short version, if you like labels
You say, “I can’t do this” (fixed). Or you say, “I can’t do this yet” (growth). That tiny word — yet — is often all that stands between a stalled project and a stubbornly persistent you who tries again, inconveniently improving as you go.
Origins and scientific background
The terms come from the work of psychologist Carol Dweck. Her research involved experiments with students, praising either their intelligence or their effort, then watching how they tackled challenges afterwards. The results were striking: praising effort led to more willingness to tackle difficult problems and to persist after failure. Praising innate ability often had the opposite effect, making people defensive or risk-averse.
You don’t need a degree in psychology to appreciate the implication: the stories you tell yourself about your abilities influence your actions. Dweck’s work has since been studied across age groups, in schools, businesses, and sports, and it has evolved to recognize that mindsets are not binary; people often harbor both, and context matters.
Important nuance
You might be thinking that a growth mindset means endless positivity and relentless optimism. It doesn’t. It means realistic optimism and intentional strategies. It accepts limits as temporary and negotiable, not as immutable facts of your identity.
Purchase The Growth Mindset Workbook
What is a Fixed Mindset?
A fixed mindset treats traits like intelligence, talent, and personality as innate and unchangeable. If you have this mindset, you often view challenges as tests of your inherent worth rather than opportunities to improve.
You may notice these thought patterns:
- You avoid situations where you might fail because failure would “prove” a lack of ability.
- You feel threatened by others’ success because it seems to highlight your own limitations.
- You prefer easy tasks so you can appear competent.
- You interpret criticism as a personal attack.
What looks like pride can be masking fear. Someone with a fixed mindset may be brilliant in one domain but terrified to face anything outside it because every new task becomes a referendum on identity.
How a fixed mindset sounds in your head
Listen to the narrative: “If I’m not good at this immediately, I must not be smart,” or, “People like me aren’t made for this kind of work.” That voice is not an oracle; it’s a habit. You can notice it and practice replying differently.
What is a Growth Mindset?
A growth mindset sees ability as a starting point that can be expanded through effort, strategies, and feedback. If you have this mindset, challenges are invitations to learn, not threats to your competence.
You might say things like:
- “I can improve with practice.”
- “Mistakes are feedback.”
- “Talent is how you use your time, not a fixed trait.”
You don’t pretend everything is easy. Instead, you reframe setbacks as data. When you fail, you ask what went wrong, not what that failure says about your soul.
How growth thinking actually behaves
Growth-minded people seek feedback, set incremental goals, and treat effort as part of the process rather than as evidence of deficiency. They also keep their egos handy, but not as shields.
Get The ‘Growth Mindset’ Quick-Start Kit
A compact comparison table
| Feature | Fixed Mindset | Growth Mindset |
|---|---|---|
| View of ability | Static trait | Can be developed |
| Response to failure | Avoids or defends | Learns and adjusts |
| Attitude toward effort | Sees effort as proof of low ability | Sees effort as path to mastery |
| Reaction to feedback | Defensive | Curious |
| Feelings about others’ success | Threatened | Inspired / informed |
This table isn’t meant to pigeonhole anyone. You can flip between columns depending on mood, context, or how well you slept.
How these mindsets show up in everyday life
You probably wear a fixed mindset in some parts of your life and a growth mindset in others. Maybe you’re confidently growth-minded about fitness because you enjoy measurable improvement, but rigidly fixed about art because you once got a discouraging critique in middle school. Mindsets are compartmentalized like drawers in an overstuffed dresser.
Here are realistic examples that might feel uncomfortably familiar to you.
At work
- Fixed: You avoid applying for a promotion because you don’t want colleagues to suspect you don’t belong.
- Growth: You apply anyway, take feedback from the interview, learn skills you lacked, and improve your candidacy.
In learning
- Fixed: You stop studying a subject after a poor grade because you decide it’s not “for you.”
- Growth: You analyze the grade, change study methods, and approach the material from a new angle.
In relationships
- Fixed: You think people can’t change, so you either stay in a pattern or bail early.
- Growth: You accept that people can learn and that communication strategies can be practiced and improved.
With hobbies
- Fixed: You quit the piano after months because you’re not a prodigy.
- Growth: You take small, consistent steps, accept imperfect progress, and keep playing because improvement is visible.
These scenarios aren’t moral judgments. They’re observations. You do what works, and sometimes what works is what feels safe rather than what leads to growth.
The benefits of a growth mindset
If you adopt a growth mindset, you can expect practical outcomes:
- Higher resilience when facing setbacks.
- Greater willingness to seek feedback and improve.
- Better long-term performance because you persist and practice.
- Greater creativity because risk-taking becomes less terrifying.
You benefit not because the world changes but because your responses do. The path is usually longer and messier, but it’s also more interesting.
The real costs of a fixed mindset
A fixed mindset limits opportunities. It narrows your risk tolerance and makes you prone to giving up at the first sign of difficulty. It also increases anxiety around performance because you treat mistakes as identity threats. In teams or families, fixed thinking can stifle growth and make honest feedback rare, which keeps everyone humbly mediocre rather than actually improving.
Common misconceptions about growth and fixed mindsets
You might have heard that praising effort is always good. But if you praise effort without paying attention to strategy or results, you can inadvertently reward endless struggle without improvement. That’s not growth; it’s martyrdom. Similarly, a growth mindset is not platitudes about “trying your best” while repeating the same ineffective action.
Other myths:
- Growth mindset equals blind positivity. No — it includes critical reflection.
- Growth mindset means never accepting limits. No — it means recognizing limits as starting points for realistic plans.
- Once you have a growth mindset, you no longer feel doubt. You will still doubt; you just respond differently.
How to shift your mindset — practical steps
You can change the habit of thinking, but it takes practice. The following steps are practical and anchored in daily behavior. Use them like tools, not as moral imperatives.
1. Notice your self-talk
You probably have looping phrases: “I’m terrible at public speaking,” or “I’m not creative.” When you hear them, pause. Naming the thought — “There’s a fixed-mindset thought” — already reduces its power.
Action: For a day, track these thoughts in a notebook or a notes app. Just notice.
2. Reframe “failure” as information
When something goes wrong, list three things that could be learned from it. Don’t be satisfied with “I did poorly”; ask “What did I miss? What hypothesis failed? What can I try next?”
Action: After a setback, write down what you learned and one concrete next step.
3. Focus on process language
Shift from “You are smart” to “Your strategy was effective,” or from “I can’t do this” to “I can work on this skill.”
Action: When you receive praise or give it, use language that highlights process, strategy, and effort plus learning.
4. Seek feedback as a resource
You don’t have to like negative feedback, but you can treat it as a map. Make a habit of asking for one thing to do differently next time.
Action: After completing something (presentation, essay, design), ask one colleague, “What’s one thing I could do to improve this next time?”
5. Practice deliberately
Deliberate practice means working on specific aspects of a skill with focused intention, not just repeating an activity. Identify the weak link and practice it.
Action: Break skills into micro-skills and practice them in short, concentrated sessions.
6. Make small bets
Don’t try to remake your brain overnight. Small, repeatable actions matter more than grand declarations.
Action: Commit to one tiny experiment each week (e.g., speak up once in a meeting, take a 10-minute writing sprint). Track progress.
7. Normalize discomfort
Growth is rarely comfortable. You can prepare yourself by acknowledging that discomfort is the price of learning.
Action: Before attempting a challenge, prepare a simple script: “This will feel awkward. That’s okay. I’m practicing.”
8. Model the mindset
If you lead others, be explicit that struggle and revision are expected. Admit mistakes and show the steps you took to improve them.
Action: In your next team meeting, share one recent mistake and what you changed as a result.
9. Reward evidence of learning, not perfection
Set milestones that celebrate incremental improvement, not flawless outcomes.
Action: Create a simple scoreboard for a skill you want to develop and reward consistent progress (not perfect results).
10. Use “yet” and other small linguistic tools
Sometimes language is the simplest lever. Adding “yet” to a sentence like “I don’t get this” transforms it into a future-oriented plan: “I don’t get this yet.”
Action: Try adding “yet” when you catch fixed-mindset thoughts for a week and notice if it shifts your energy.
A second useful table: tactics, what to say, and why it helps
| Tactic | What you might say | Why it helps |
|---|---|---|
| Reframe failure | “This outcome tells me what to fix.” | Turns emotion into data |
| Process praise | “Your research method was thorough.” | Highlights controllable actions |
| Micro-goals | “I’ll practice 15 minutes a day.” | Builds consistency without overwhelm |
| Feedback request | “What’s one change you’d suggest?” | Makes critiques actionable |
| Publicizing mistakes | “Here’s what I screwed up and how I fixed it.” | Models learning for others |
| Deliberate practice | “I’ll isolate this subskill today.” | Targets the weakest link for faster improvement |
Exercises to practice right away
You should do these in short, controlled doses. They are designed to feel slightly awkward (that’s the point), then gradually less awkward.
Exercise 1: The 7-minute audit
- Spend seven minutes writing every fixed-mindset thought you had today.
- Pick one and write down the evidence for and against it.
- Write a single alternative growth-minded sentence replacing it.
Exercise 2: The “What Went Wrong” log
- After any setback, write three hypotheses about why it happened and one experiment you’ll run to test a hypothesis.
Exercise 3: Feedback roulette
- Ask three people for one piece of feedback and one suggestion for improvement. Keep the feedback focused and executable.
Exercise 4: Reverse praise
- When praising someone, deliberately avoid praising innate traits. Instead, say, “I noticed your approach to solving X — it helped me learn Y.”
These exercises are simple and occasionally embarrassing. You’ll be fine. You might also annoy your coworkers briefly. That will pass.
For parents, teachers, and managers
If you guide people, your language matters more than you think. Children and direct reports take cues about what you value.
- Praise process, not person. You can say, “You worked really hard on that,” or “I liked how you revised after feedback.”
- Model vulnerability. When you make a mistake, say what you learned and what you’ll change.
- Set learning goals alongside performance goals. “This month we’ll improve call-handling techniques; we’ll measure practice time and skill gain.”
Be mindful: telling a child “You’re so smart” feels kind, but it can make them fragile in the face of difficulty. Saying, “You tried different strategies and found one that worked” equips them to repeat the approach.
Potential pitfalls and cautions
There are ways to misunderstand growth mindset that make it worse than the original fixed thinking.
- Overvalorizing effort: Telling someone to “try harder” without considering strategy or systemic barriers is unhelpful. Effort must be paired with learning, coaching, and structural support.
- Blaming the learner: Don’t use growth mindset language to blame people for failing in contexts where they lacked resources.
- Weaponizing growth: Leaders can misuse growth language to push people into unsafe workload or to justify poor systems. Growth mindset doesn’t mean you shouldn’t also fix systems that hinder development.
You need both compassion and accountability. Growth mindset without compassion slips into harsh self-blame. Growth mindset without accountability becomes vague affirmations with nothing to show for them.
How to measure progress
Measuring mindset change is a little like measuring patience: indirect and messy. But you can track behaviors that indicate growth thinking.
Signs of progress:
- You ask for feedback more often.
- You try tasks outside your comfort zone with more frequency.
- You reframe mistakes as data instead of identity threats.
- You change strategies based on outcomes.
Concrete metrics:
- Number of experiments you run per month.
- Frequency of feedback requests.
- Time spent in deliberate practice.
- Variety of new tasks attempted.
Keep the metrics reasonable and humane. You’re trying to evolve, not to win an endurance contest.
Frequently asked questions
Can people change from fixed to growth?
Yes. Change is gradual and often uneven. You can cultivate growth habits and slow the reflex to interpret setbacks as identity judgments. Expect relapses; they are part of the process.
Is talent irrelevant if you have a growth mindset?
No. Talent may give someone an early advantage, but long-term success tends to be more closely tied to sustained effort and good strategies. A growth mindset helps you turn potential into performance.
Can you have a growth mindset in one area and a fixed mindset in another?
Absolutely. You might be growth-minded about your body because you track workouts religiously and fixed-minded about math because of an early bad teacher. The compartments are normal and changeable.
Is growth mindset just positive thinking?
Not at all. It’s a disciplined approach to improvement that combines humility, humility’s partner patience, and methods for learning.
How can I help someone who resists changing?
Start by reducing threats. Praise specific actions, share your own mistakes and what you learned, and invite small experiments rather than issuing mandates. Provide resources and reduce the stigma of failure.
You, in practice: a short case study
Imagine you sign up for a painting class because, for reasons you can’t explain, you thought 38 was the right age to take up tempera. At the first critique, you realize your color mixing is beginner-level and your composition is clumsy. The fixed-mindset you knows the script: it’s evidence you always lacked an artistic bone. The growth-minded you mentions that word “yet” and then does something boring but effective: practices color wheels for 15 minutes daily, studies composition in short sketches, and asks the instructor one specific question after each class.
Three months later your paintings still have the awkwardness that makes family friends nod politely, but your compositions start to look intentional. You still have feelings — jealousy, embarrassment — but there’s also a lot of small, measurable progress. The growth path doesn’t make you a prodigy overnight. It makes you someone who gets better in a way that is both humbling and satisfying.
Final thoughts
You can treat mindsets like wardrobe choices: some days you wear the fixed sweater because it’s comfortable and familiar; other days you put on the growth coat because you plan to get somewhere and you need pockets for tools. Neither item defines your whole closet.
Changing the way you think about ability is less about adopting a mantra and more about adopting practices that rewire your habits. You will stumble; you’ll probably say the old thing out loud at a bad moment. Catch yourself, make a small pivot, and go on. Over time, the language you use — to yourself and to others — will change the story you live.
If nothing else, you’ll become a person who tolerates discomfort a little better and who treats feedback as a map rather than as a verdict. That alone is a very useful new hobby.